The fork feels too soft for your weight, and you're wondering whether to add air or swap a spring. The answer depends on which kind of spring is inside, so check that first.
The two kinds
A fork spring can be a steel or titanium coil, or compressed air1. A coil fork has a metal spring in it. An air fork has a sealed chamber of air, and a small valve, usually under a cap, where you add air.
If you can see that valve, you've got an air spring. If you can't, read the label on the lower leg and then the manual.
How each one is adjusted
On an air fork, you change the pressure. The spring rate can easily be adjusted that way, by changing the air pressure1. You'd use a shock pump, which isn't the same as a normal tire pump2.
On a coil fork, the spring itself sets the stiffness. Preload on a coil fork can generally be adjusted with a knob on top of one leg1. Preload changes how far the fork sinks at rest: more preload means less sag1. It doesn't turn a soft spring into a firm one.
| Air spring | Coil spring | |
|---|---|---|
| What pushes back | Compressed air | A metal coil |
| Main adjustment | Air pressure | Spring choice, plus a preload knob on some forks |
| Tool | Shock pump | Whatever your maker's manual lists |
How they feel
Coil forks keep an approximately constant spring rate through their travel1. Air forks get firmer as they go deeper, which makes them progressive1. The same source adds that air forks are generally lighter1.
What each one needs
Fox's older owner's manual gives each spring type its own service table. There's one for air spring forks and one for coil spring forks3. The air table includes changing the FLOAT fluid in the air chamber on some models. The coil table doesn't list that3.
That's one maker. Its manual dates from 20113. Newer forks and other makers may differ, so read the manual that came with your bike, or the maker's support page for your model and year.
Which one is on your bike
Don't guess from looks alone. Some forks hide the spring completely inside the leg, and a coil fork and an air fork can look alike from the outside.
Three checks, in order:
- Is there a valve cap near the top of a leg? That points to air.
- Does the fork's lower leg carry a label or sticker with the model name? Search that name on the maker's site.
- Does the bike's manual or spec sheet say "air" or "coil"? Many do.
If you can't find a pressure or spring chart for your fork, don't guess. Ask a dealer or the maker. The page on what sag means shows where those numbers usually live. Stuck? Stop there.
For what the spring is doing in the first place, the opening page of this site has the plain version: the basics.
Where the facts come from
- Bicycle suspension, Wikipedia
- How to set the SAG on your E-MTB Suspension in ten Minutes, E-MOUNTAINBIKE Magazine
- Service Intervals (Fox owner's manual, 2011), FOX Factory